Skip to content

Ein 4

Discussion Prep — Chang Yu, LEO Debris

  1. You compare LEO to oceans — but ocean governance has largely failed (overfishing, plastic, territorial disputes). Why would space governance succeed where oceans haven't?
  2. If we regulate now, doesn't that just lock in whoever launched first? How is that "equitable access" for emerging space nations?
  3. Should we evaluate constellations individually by purpose (Starlink broadband vs. climate monitoring vs. military), or is any expansion risky regardless?
  4. You mention ephemeris sharing is "almost nonexistent" between competing nations. Is that a technical problem or a political one? Does the solution change depending on the answer?
  5. Debris at 800 km lasts centuries. Are engineers today imposing risk on future generations who have no say and may lack cleanup technology? Is that fair?
  6. NASA and ESA already have end-of-life disposal guidelines — so is the Pawley critique really about engineering culture, or about the fact that compliance is voluntary?

  7. At ~7.5 km/s orbital velocity, a 1 cm debris fragment carries roughly the kinetic energy of a hand grenade

  8. The 2009 Iridium-Cosmos collision created over 2,000 tracked fragments, many still in orbit
  9. SpaceX alone has ~6,000+ Starlink satellites in LEO as of 2026; approved for up to ~12,000, applied for ~30,000 more
  10. The 2007 Chinese anti-satellite test (Fengyun-1C) created ~3,500 tracked debris pieces at ~865 km — an altitude where drag is negligible, so most are still there
  11. Only ~30% of defunct satellites are successfully deorbited within guidelines (25-year rule, now moving to 5-year)
  12. The Outer Space Treaty (1967) assigns liability to launching states but has no enforcement mechanism for debris

  13. Bateson needs teeth, not just philosophy. Flexibility is a nice concept, but in practice it means: every satellite added shrinks the available safe-maneuver space for everyone else. That's a measurable engineering constraint (conjunction rate, available delta-v for avoidance), not just a metaphor.

  14. The tragedy of the commons is already happening. No single operator has incentive to limit their constellation because the cost of debris is shared by everyone. Chang identifies this but doesn't name it — classic commons problem, and commons problems don't solve themselves through goodwill.
  15. First-mover advantage undermines fairness arguments. Any framework built now effectively grandfathers SpaceX and OneWeb while constraining Indian, African, and South American space programs that are just getting started. Regulation that arrives after incumbents are established isn't neutral.
  16. "Benefits justify risks" needs specifics. Chang lists telecom, climate, weather as benefits but doesn't quantify. Rural broadband is real but serves commercial interests. Climate monitoring is public good. Lumping them together dodges the harder question of which uses justify the debris risk.
  17. The cleanup gap. We can put satellites up but have no proven, scalable technology to remove debris. Engineering a system you can't clean up is a design failure by any ethical framework, not just Bateson's.