Ein2
You're the Investigator today, so you're not moderating — the critic runs the clock. Your job is to open with a seed question and then keep the discussion deep and multi-perspective. Here's what to have ready.
Your one job at:30 (or:18 if the critic opens the floor to you): open with a seed question and get people talking. Don't lecture the article — they've read it. Best opener is question 1, the 1-in-10,000 one. It's concrete, everyone can hold it in their head, and it splits the room immediately.
The 90-second setup, if you need to frame before the first question:
Stuttgart researchers are melting satellite parts in plasma wind tunnels because nobody actually knows what happens when a satellite burns up. Two findings drive it: the ash might deplete ozone, and some parts — titanium, Inconel — don't burn up at all, which a battery pallet proved by going through a Florida roof. Meanwhile, the fleet is going from 18,000 satellites to hundreds of thousands. That's the whole tension: the responsible fix, deorbiting, dumps the problem into the one layer of atmosphere nobody watches.
Facilitation moves — this is where the rubric points actually are:
- When someone gives an opinion, ask for the argument: "what's that resting on?" You're graded on drawing out supported perspectives, not opinions.
- Assign perspectives if the room stalls: "someone take the operator's side — why is this overblown?" You need five-plus distinct views on record.
- Keep the FAA thread in your pocket as fuel, not the topic. Deploy it when energy dips: "researchers say make the rules stricter; the FAA just proposed waiving 13 environmental laws — who's right?"
- Names are your ammunition — Müller on aggregation, the Inconel cylinder, the Falcon 9 lithium plume, the Montreal Protocol precedent.
The four hard pushbacks you should have an answer for:
- "44 tonnes of space rock hits us daily — satellites are a rounding error." → Volume isn't the point;
-
chemistry is. Rock is silicon; satellites are aluminum and titanium, deposited at 60–80 km where there's no removal mechanism. Different substance, different layer.
-
"This is speculative — we don't even know if it forms harmful oxide." → That's exactly the ethical question, not a reason to dismiss it. The models split between ozone-depleting oxide and benign hydroxide. So which error do you want — restrict something harmless, or permit something irreversible at global scale?
-
"Companies already design for demise; SpaceX says Starlink fully burns up." → It's an unverified public safety claim. NASA said the same about the battery pallet. Stuttgart couldn't melt the matching cylinder on any trajectory. Who checks the claim?
-
"If the US regulates, China just launches anyway." → True, and it makes it a collective-action problem, not a reason to do nothing. Same structure as the Montreal Protocol, which actually worked internationally.
Two things to nail before you walk in: which seed question you're opening with, and confirm the critic is posting notes to Slack the same day — your final analysis Sep 24 needs every perspective raised today. Want me to run a quick mock — I play a skeptical group member and you facilitate?