Ein2

You're the Investigator today, so you're not moderating — the critic runs the clock. Your job is to open with a seed question and then keep the discussion deep and multi-perspective. Here's what to have ready.

Your one job at:30 (or:18 if the critic opens the floor to you): open with a seed question and get people talking. Don't lecture the article — they've read it. Best opener is question 1, the 1-in-10,000 one. It's concrete, everyone can hold it in their head, and it splits the room immediately.

The 90-second setup, if you need to frame before the first question:
Stuttgart researchers are melting satellite parts in plasma wind tunnels because nobody actually knows what happens when a satellite burns up. Two findings drive it: the ash might deplete ozone, and some parts — titanium, Inconel — don't burn up at all, which a battery pallet proved by going through a Florida roof. Meanwhile, the fleet is going from 18,000 satellites to hundreds of thousands. That's the whole tension: the responsible fix, deorbiting, dumps the problem into the one layer of atmosphere nobody watches.

Facilitation moves — this is where the rubric points actually are:

  • When someone gives an opinion, ask for the argument: "what's that resting on?" You're graded on drawing out supported perspectives, not opinions.
  • Assign perspectives if the room stalls: "someone take the operator's side — why is this overblown?" You need five-plus distinct views on record.
  • Keep the FAA thread in your pocket as fuel, not the topic. Deploy it when energy dips: "researchers say make the rules stricter; the FAA just proposed waiving 13 environmental laws — who's right?"
  • Names are your ammunition — Müller on aggregation, the Inconel cylinder, the Falcon 9 lithium plume, the Montreal Protocol precedent.

The four hard pushbacks you should have an answer for:

  1. "44 tonnes of space rock hits us daily — satellites are a rounding error." → Volume isn't the point;
  2. chemistry is. Rock is silicon; satellites are aluminum and titanium, deposited at 60–80 km where there's no removal mechanism. Different substance, different layer.

  3. "This is speculative — we don't even know if it forms harmful oxide." → That's exactly the ethical question, not a reason to dismiss it. The models split between ozone-depleting oxide and benign hydroxide. So which error do you want — restrict something harmless, or permit something irreversible at global scale?

  4. "Companies already design for demise; SpaceX says Starlink fully burns up." → It's an unverified public safety claim. NASA said the same about the battery pallet. Stuttgart couldn't melt the matching cylinder on any trajectory. Who checks the claim?

  5. "If the US regulates, China just launches anyway." → True, and it makes it a collective-action problem, not a reason to do nothing. Same structure as the Montreal Protocol, which actually worked internationally.

Two things to nail before you walk in: which seed question you're opening with, and confirm the critic is posting notes to Slack the same day — your final analysis Sep 24 needs every perspective raised today. Want me to run a quick mock — I play a skeptical group member and you facilitate?