EE156 Midterm — Study Guide (v2: lectures + homework)
Window: Mon Oct 12 → Sun Oct 18. Exam assumed Mon Oct 19; adjust if your CBTF slot differs.
Companion files: ee156-practice-problems.md (152 problems, worked answers, every number script-verified) and ee156-cheatsheet.md (formulas, lists and traps).
Coverage: lectures 1B–8A and HW1–HW7. Lecture 8A (Statement of Cash Flows, Double-Entry Accounting) wasn't on your original topic list, so it's now on Day 6.
This guide has three parts: 1. The 7-day schedule: what to read, watch and practice each day. 2. Concept notes: the full content of every lecture, organized by deck. Use these as your main review text. 3. Discrepancies and traps: places where the homework solutions, lectures and textbook disagree.
How each day runs
- Warm-up (15 min): redo yesterday's starred problems cold.
- Lecture pass (45–60 min): read the day's concept notes below with the slide deck open, and pause on every worked example. The exam is built from the decks and the readings.
- Videos (30–60 min): the short ones listed for the day. Use the long lectures only when a concept doesn't click.
- Practice (1.5–2 h): the day's block of problems → the free BMA chapter quiz → the MIT 15.401 PDF section where listed. Grade yourself against the answers and star every miss.
- Lock-in (15 min): write every formula you used from memory, check it against the cheatsheet, and star what you missed.
Core practice resources (used all week)
- BMA free chapter quizzes (auto-graded, 15 MC each, the closest thing to CBTF):
https://highered.mheducation.com/sites/0077151569/student_view0/chapter{N}/multiple_choice_quiz.html. Replace{N}with the chapter number. - MIT 15.401 Problems & Solutions PDF (problems pp. 1–35, solutions pp. 36–73): link. Its parts are Present Value, Fixed Income and Common Stock.
- OpenStax Principles of Finance 2e end-of-chapter MC and problems:
https://openstax.org/books/principles-finance-2e/pages/{N}-multiple-choice. There's no public answer key, so check your numbers with the calculators below. - Your own homework. HW1–HW6 solutions are in the project. Redo HW2 Q2–Q3, HW3 Q1–Q3, HW5 Q1–Q5 and HW6 Q1–Q3 cold. These are the most exam-like numeric problems you have.
- Checkers: calculator.net finance, bond calculator, or Excel
PV/FV/PMT/RATE/PRICE/YIELD/MDURATION. - Full-course backup: MIT 15.401 playlist · Shiller Financial Markets
Part 1 — 7-Day Schedule
Day 1 — Mon Oct 12 · Time Value of Money, NPV, IRR
Decks: L1B (Intro & TVM) and the first half of L2A (perpetuities, annuities, compounding, IRR). Reading: BMA Ch 2. HW: HW1 Q3–Q4, HW2 Q1, Q3, Q5.
Watch - Present Value Relations II — MIT 15.401 Ses 3 (1:20). Covers perpetuities, annuities, growing perpetuities and compounding. Watch at 1.5×. - APR and effective APR — Khan Academy (7 min) - Optional: Growing Perpetuity & Annuity (8 min; embedding is off, so open it on youtube.com) · PV Relations I — Ses 2
Practice: problems A1–A16 → BMA quiz ch2 → MIT PDF Part 1 (Present Value).
Must be able to: - Give the three reasons a dollar today beats a dollar tomorrow, and compute total cost = direct + opportunity cost. - Value a perpetuity, perpetuity-due, delayed perpetuity, growing perpetuity, annuity and growing annuity. - Derive \(e^{rt}\). - Convert APR, EAR and per-period rates. A quarterly rate from an EAR is the 4th root of \((1+\text{EAR})\), not EAR/4. - Build an amortization schedule and work through rent-vs-buy. - Compute NPV and IRR, and know IRR's caveats.
Day 2 — Tue Oct 13 (today) · Bonds, YTM, Bond Markets, Yield Curve
Decks: L2A (second half, bonds) and L2B. Reading: BMA 3-1 to 3-4. HW: HW2 Q2, Q4.
Watch - Bond prices and interest rates — Khan Academy (13 min) - Spot Rates and Forward Rates — Ryan O'Connell (6 min) - 3 Theories of the Yield Curve — Edspira (4 min) - Deeper: Fixed-Income Securities II — MIT Ses 5 · Ses 6 · Shiller: Term Structure
Practice: problems A17–A30 → BMA quiz ch3 → MIT PDF Part 2 (Fixed Income). Hands-on (15 min): pull today's Treasury par yield curve. Note the 2s10s spread and whether the curve is inverted.
Must be able to: - Price semiannual Treasuries and STRIPS (both quoted with semiannual compounding). - Tell premium, par and discount apart without calculating. - Read quotes as a % of face. - Define current yield, YTM, yield to call and yield to worst. - Explain why curves usually slope up (term premium), what causes inversion (aggressive tightening), and why two same-currency countries can have different curves. - Say what happens to coupon, price and YTM when rates rise after issue. - Explain on-the-run vs off-the-run issues and short-selling mechanics.
Day 3 — Wed Oct 14 · Duration, Convexity, Credit, Real Rates, TIPS
Decks: L3A and L3B. Reading: BMA 3-5, 3-6; Hull 4.10–4.12. HW: HW3 (all), HW6 Q1.4.
Watch - Bond Duration and Convexity Explained — Ryan O'Connell (9 min) - Macaulay Duration → Modified Duration, both Edspira (15 min) - Credit Ratings AAA to Default (10 min), or Credit Spread — CFI (1.5 min) - Nominal vs real returns and inflation — Khan Academy (4 min) - What are TIPS (6 min) - Deeper: Fixed-Income IV — MIT Ses 7
Practice: problems B1–B29 → AnalystPrep duration + convexity and convexity (MC at the bottom of each page) → MIT midterm solutions, Q1 only. Hands-on (10 min): check on FRED T10YIE that the 10y nominal yield minus the 10y TIPS yield ≈ breakeven.
Must be able to: - Price a bond off a semiannual spot curve. - Compute Macaulay and modified duration (r per period) and prove \(D_{mod} = -\frac{1}{P}\frac{dP}{dr}\). - Estimate ΔP with duration plus convexity (a two-term Taylor series). - Know that duration is never negative but convexity can be (MBS, callables). - Know that same-coupon curves cross at par. - Explain why spreads widen with maturity, what "trading credit" means, duration-matched spread trades, and the flight-to-safety trade. - Use Fisher exact vs approximate, compute TIPS nominal IRR, and know the TIPS principal floor and the breakeven trade.
HW7 is due tonight at 11:59 PM. It's all Day 6 material (governance, balance sheet, income statement), so read the L7A/L7B notes below before starting it.
Day 4 — Thu Oct 15 · Stocks, Markets, Valuation, ROI
Decks: L4A, L4B and L5A. Reading: BMA 4-1 to 4-5; Malkiel Ch 1–6. HW: HW4 (all), HW5 Q1–Q3, HW6 Q4, Q7.
Watch - A Random Walk Down Wall Street summary (15 min) - Primary vs Secondary Market (3 min) - Dividend Discount Model — Edspira (7 min) - Present Value of Growth Opportunities (8 min) - Sustainable Growth Rate (6 min) - Deeper: Equities — MIT Ses 8 · P/E ratio — Khan · FCF/FCFE/FCFF — CFI - Optional: Dot-com bubble — Plain Bagel
Practice: problems C1–C32 → BMA quiz ch4 → MIT PDF Part 3 (Common Stock).
Must be able to: - Explain why firms issue stock, common vs preferred, hybrids, covenants, value vs growth, and the ex-dividend price drop. - Describe how each index is built (and why the DJIA is "the worst, most quoted"), the 8 trading and investing strategies, and the SEC filings (10-K, 10-Q, 8-K, 13D/G). - Compute P/E, earnings yield and EPS, and know the four valuation methods. - Do comps on P/E and P/S, Gordon growth, and DCF vs DDM. - Size a cash-neutral pair trade. - Compute CAGR (price-only vs total return with reinvested dividends) and Malkiel's market-return estimate (yield + growth + P/E change). - Distinguish primary vs secondary markets, buy side vs sell side, clearinghouses and block trades.
Day 5 — Fri Oct 16 · Risk, Diversification, CAPM, Market Efficiency, Corporate Finance
Decks: L5B, L6A and L6B. Reading: BMA Ch 7–8, 12-2, Ch 14; Malkiel Ch 7–9. HW: HW5 Q4–Q5, HW6 Q1–Q3, Q5–Q6.
Watch - Risk and Return of a Two-Asset Portfolio (3.5 min) - Systematic vs Unsystematic Risk — Edspira (7.5 min) - CAPM & Security Market Line (8 min) - Efficient Frontier Explained (13 min) - Capital Market Line — Edspira (6 min) - Efficient Capital Markets — Ben Felix (14 min) - Corporate Finance: What is it? — Damodaran (18 min) - Deeper: MIT Ses 13 · Ses 14 · Shiller: Diversification & CAPM · Shiller: Efficient Markets · Shiller: Behavioral Finance
Practice: problems D1–D30 → BMA quizzes ch7, ch8, ch13 → OpenStax ch15 MC. Hands-on (15 min): in Portfolio Visualizer, use two assets and watch the bullet bend as ρ goes from 1 to −1.
Must be able to: - Explain volatility vs probability of loss, and compute VaR (\(z = 2.33\)). - Distinguish market vs idiosyncratic risk. Market risk can't be diversified away but can be hedged. - Compute two-asset σ and draw the bullet at ρ = ±1. - Use a zero-coupon Treasury matched to the horizon as \(r_f\). - Compute the Sharpe ratio and the max-Sharpe portfolio on a grid. - Compute \(\beta = \rho\sigma_i/\sigma_m\) and work the SML, alpha, the lecture's CAPM assumptions, the tangency = market mechanism, and CAPM as a single-factor model vs Fama-French. - Explain the three EMH forms and the evidence for each. - Compare entity types (sole prop, partnership, LLC, S-corp, C-corp) and explain why VCs want C-corps.
Day 6 — Sat Oct 17 · Governance, Accounting, Balance Sheet, Income Statement, Cash Flows, Double Entry
Decks: L7A, L7B and L8A. Reading: Ittelson Ch 1–2. HW: HW7 (all).
Watch - Agency Theory with examples (8 min) - Introduction to GAAP — Edspira (5 min) - Financial Statements in 8 Minutes — Accounting Stuff (9 min) - Balance Sheet + Income Statement for beginners (12 min) - The Accounting Equation for Beginners (5 min) - How the 3 statements link (9 min) - For L8A, search Accounting Stuff's channel for "Debits and Credits" and "Cash Flow Statement". I haven't checked those links, so find them by title.
Practice: problems E1–E31 → BMA quizzes ch12, ch28, ch29 → AccountingCoach balance sheet, income statement and financial ratios quizzes.
Must be able to: - Explain board vs Chairman vs CEO powers, how shareholders exert influence, and activists. - Compare cash vs accrual accounting, GAAP scope, the three accounting branches and the Big Four. - Trace any transaction through A = L + E. - Compute the current, quick, cash, D/E (interest-bearing debt only) and L/A ratios. - Explain goodwill (acquisitions only; annual impairment test). - Separate COGS vs opex, fixed vs variable vs semi-variable costs, and compute gross, operating and net margins. Know EBIT's synonyms and below-the-line items. - Classify CFO/CFI/CFF and build an indirect-method cash flow statement. - Write debits and credits and journal entries, and use the expanded accounting equation.
Day 7 — Sun Oct 18 · Mock Exams & Consolidation
- Morning (2 h, timed, closed book except the cheatsheet):
- MIT 15.401 midterm, graded against the solutions.
- Then the TVM, bonds, spot/forward and stocks sections of the final, checked against the answers.
- Afternoon (2 h): mixed review. Pick every 5th problem from each block (A5, A10, …, E30), then redo every starred problem. Retake any BMA chapter quiz where you scored under 12/15.
- Evening (1 h): write the cheatsheet from memory on blank paper, section by section. Drill anything you can't write. Then sleep.
Exam morning (20 min): read the cheatsheet's traps, then redo these cold: - A8: perpetuity timing. - A18: semiannual pricing. - B1: spot-curve pricing. - C22: Gordon growth. - D16: max-Sharpe portfolio. - E23: indirect cash flow statement.
Topic → resource map
| # | Topic | Decks | Problems | HW | BMA quiz ch | MIT PDF |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | TVM, NPV, IRR | L1B, L2A | A1–A16 | HW1 Q3–4, HW2 Q1, Q3, Q5 | 2 | Part 1 |
| 2 | Bonds, YTM | L2A, L2B | A17–A24 | HW2 Q2, Q4.4 | 3 | Part 2 |
| 3 | Bond markets, yield curve | L2B | A25–A30 | HW2 Q4 | 3 | Part 2 |
| 4 | Duration, convexity, credit | L3A | B1–B22 | HW3 Q1–Q2, HW6 Q1.4 | 3, 23 | Part 2 |
| 5 | Real rates, TIPS | L3B | B23–B29 | HW3 Q3 | 3 | — |
| 6 | Stocks, markets, indices, strategies, filings | L4A, L4B | C1–C18, C30–C32 | HW4 Q1–Q4, HW6 Q7 | 4 | — |
| 7 | Stock valuation | L4B | C19–C24 | HW4 Q5, HW5 Q1 | 4 | Part 3 |
| 8 | ROI, CAGR, Malkiel returns | L5A | C25–C29 | HW5 Q2–Q3, HW6 Q4 | 4 | Part 3 |
| 9 | Risk, diversification | L5B | D1–D15 | HW5 Q4–Q5, HW6 Q1 | 7 | — |
| 10 | CAPM, Sharpe, beta | L6A | D16–D27 | HW6 Q2–Q3, Q5 | 8 | — |
| 11 | EMH, corporate finance, entities | L6B | D28–D30 (+ D-block MC) | HW6 Q5.7, Q6 | 13, 14 | — |
| 12 | Governance, accounting basics | L7A | E1–E8 | HW7 Q1–Q2 | 1, 12 | — |
| 13 | Balance sheet, goodwill, income statement | L7B | E9–E21 | HW7 Q3–Q4 | 28, 29 | — |
| 14 | Cash flows, double entry | L8A | E22–E31 | — | 28 | — |
Part 2 — Concept Notes (from the lecture decks)
These notes draw on every slide in L1B–L8A, plus the reasoning in the homework solutions. Lecture tags like "(L3A)" show the source. Where a deck's formulas were images and didn't extract, the standard textbook form is used; Part 3 lists those cases.
A — Time Value of Money, Interest Rates & Bonds, Yield Curve (L1B, L2A, L2B)
L1B — Intro & Time Value of Money
Opportunity cost = value of the next best alternative forfeited. Total cost = direct cost + opportunity cost. JP's MBA example: tuition + fees ≈ $160K, plus 2 years of salary, work experience, career advancement.
TVM: "A dollar today is worth more than a dollar tomorrow" — always, for a rational person, even under deflation. Three reasons (L1B): 1. opportunity to invest earlier 2. impatience (preference for liquidity) 3. uncertainty (you might not get the dollar)
Future value. Risk-free bank deposit, \(r = 7\%\), 2 years: \(100(1.07)^2 = \$114.49\) = principal $100 + interest $14.49 (annual compounding). \(r\) here is the APR — a legal and financial concept; hidden fees must by law be embedded in the APR.
Rule of 72: years to double \(\approx 72/r\) with \(r\) in percent (7% → 10.29 yrs). Exact: \(T = \ln 2/\ln(1+r)\). HW1 Q3: within 0.25 yr for 5%–33%; underestimates at low rates (1%: 69.66 vs 72), overestimates at high rates. The "ideal" constant \(rT\) rises with \(r\) (69.7 at 1%, 72.1 at 8%, 72.7 at 10%) — 72 is exact near 8%.
Present value. PV of $114.49 in 2 yrs at 7% is $100; \(r\) is now the discount rate. A long-term investor is indifferent between the two. Each date has a discount factor \(DF_t = 1/(1+r)^t\) (positive, < 1). Value a stream: PV each flow, then add.
NPV. Cash flows can be + or −. Forecast expected flows, pick \(r\), sum all flows including \(C_0\): \(NPV = C_0 + \sum_{t\ge1} C_t/(1+r)^t\) — the DCF formula, basis of a common company-valuation method. NPV > 0 → do it; < 0 → don't.
Risk. "A safe dollar is worth more than a risky dollar." Investors demand a higher expected return for risk; demanded rate − risk-free rate = risk premium. Discount at the opportunity cost of capital (OCC) = market return on investments of similar risk. OCC is measured in %, not $. In practice estimated with comps (L2A).
Rate of return \(= \text{profit}/\text{investment}\); compare to OCC. Two equivalent rules: positive NPV ⇔ rate of return > OCC.
Perpetuity (first payment at \(t=1\), none at \(t=0\)): \(PV = C/r\). Endowment question: to fund \(C\)/yr forever at return \(r\), deposit \(C/r\) — same question, same formula.
L2A — Interest Rates and Bonds
Risk-free rate: Treasury yields, set by a market process (auctions, then public trading) — hence they change over time.
Annuity (\(t\) payments, first at \(t=1\)): \(PV = C\left[\frac1r - \frac{1}{r(1+r)^t}\right]\). Mortgage = annuity; solve for \(C\) (HW2 Q5.4).
Growing perpetuity / annuity (payments grow by factor \(1+g\), first payment \(C_1\) at \(t=1\), need \(r>g\)): \(PV = \frac{C_1}{r-g}\), \(\quad PV = \frac{C_1}{r-g}\left[1 - \frac{(1+g)^t}{(1+r)^t}\right]\). HW2 derivations (official method — no series formula needed): - Perpetuity: write \(X\), multiply by \(\frac1{1+r}\), subtract → \(X = C/r\). - Perpetuity-due (first payment now): \(C + C/r = C(1+r)/r\) — equals the ordinary perpetuity rolled forward one period. - Growing perpetuity: multiply by \(\frac{1+g}{1+r}\), subtract; \(1-\frac{1+g}{1+r} = \frac{r-g}{1+r}\). - Growing annuity = perpetuity A (from \(t=1\)) − perpetuity B (from \(t+1\); worth \(\frac{C_1(1+g)^t}{r-g}\) at time \(t\), discount \(t\) periods). Checks: \(t\to\infty\) → \(C_1/(r-g)\); \(g=0\) → ordinary annuity.
APR vs EAR. APR = stated rate, ignores compounding; APR/\(n\) = per-period rate. EAR (effective APR) = actual annual rate: \(EAR = (1+r/n)^n - 1\). Lecture example: 10% APR semiannual → 5%/half-year → \(1.05^2 = 1.1025\) → EAR 10.25%. EAR rises with compounding frequency. 1 bp = 0.01%.
Continuous compounding (\(n\to\infty\)): \(EAR = e^r - 1\); growth factor \(e^{rt}\) over \(t\) years. Calculus proof (HW2 Q1.1): \(dA/dt = rA \Rightarrow \ln(A/A_0) = rt \Rightarrow A = A_0e^{rt}\); lecture also showed the limit proof. ≈ daily compounding (5%: 5.1271% vs 5.1267%). Common in quant finance only.
Bonds. An IOU: buyer lends to the issuer for coupons (interest) + face value (principal) at maturity. Most pay every six months. Stocks and bonds are securities; currencies and commodities are not (SEC Howey Test).
Issuers: national govts (US Treasuries, JGBs, UK Gilts, French OATs); agencies (Fannie Mae/FNMA buys mortgages, Ginnie Mae/GNMA guarantees them); municipalities (schools, roads, transit); corporations — investment grade = BBB and above, high yield ("junk") = BB and below (Moody's etc.).
Quoting: price as % of face. $1M bond at 100 = $1M (par); 99.5 = $995,000 (discount); 100.5 = $1,005,000 (premium). Zero-coupon: single "bullet" payment of face at maturity; trades at a discount. A coupon bond = portfolio of zeros.
IRR: discount rate making NPV = 0. Caveats (L2A): - implicitly assumes intermediate cash flows reinvested at the IRR - usually needs numerical methods - not unique when cash flows change sign multiple times - NPV comparison is generally preferred
YTM: IRR of the bond held to maturity; most common bond ROI measure; accounts for price, coupon, face; compounding frequency = coupon frequency; often just "yield"; moves opposite to price; bonds quoted in price or yield.
Other yields: current yield = annual coupon / price; nominal yield (coupon rate) = annual coupon / par; YTC = yield assuming called at earliest date; YTW = lowest yield across scenarios (call vs maturity).
L2B — Bond Markets and the Yield Curve
Bond ROI (PIMCO reading — "Bond King" Bill Gross, left 2014) = coupon income + capital gain/loss (vs sale price, or par if held). Long bonds riskier: default risk + rate sensitivity. Duration = weighted-average time to payments; measures price sensitivity to rates.
Retail quotes (Schwab): thin ("illiquid") retail markets → inappropriately high prices / low yields.
Short selling — car analogy: borrow parents' car, sell it, you're "short" one car, must buy one back to "cover"; parents forcing you to buy early = margin call. Real markets: short sellers post margin (collateral, % of value); price rises → margin call; can't meet it → forced buyback; many at once → short squeeze. Shorting increases the float. Long = own, want price up; short = borrowed & sold, want price down.
Yield → price: \(P = \sum_{k=1}^{2T}\frac{c/2}{(1+y/2)^k} + \frac{100}{(1+y/2)^{2T}}\) = annuity + bullet. Price = PV at YTM (as APR) ⇔ YTM = IRR. Solving \(y\) from \(P\) needs numerical methods. Slide example: coupon term with \(/2\) → semiannual, 7% coupon.
Recap: prices and yields move opposite. "Bond market is rallying" = rates going down. Bond market = real-time market for loans. Bondholder wants rates down. Bull market/rally: rates ↓ prices ↑; bear/sell-off: rates ↑ prices ↓.
Treasuries: Bills < 1 yr, zero-coupon (4, 8, 13, 26, 52 wk); Notes 2, 3, 5, 7, 10 yr; Bonds 20, 30 yr. New 10-yr vs 20-year-old 30-yr bond: coupons usually differ; even if equal, market prefers the on-the-run 10-yr — better liquidity, tighter bid-ask.
Liquidity: bid = buyer's price, offer/ask = seller's; liquidity = ease of trading without moving price; measured by bid-ask tightness and market depth. Fixed income < 1 yr = money market (near-cash).
Market facts: "Rates" = rate-sensitive bonds, "Credit" = credit-risk-sensitive. Issuance growing: more govt borrowing; corporates issuing bonds instead of bank loans. Equity issuance ≪ bond issuance because bonds mature and must be rolled; equities never mature. Post-COVID issuance spike (low rates). ABS = auto loans, student loans, card receivables. FX is the largest market by volume. Yields mean-revert; 10-yr long-run average ≈ 6%, last 20 years ≈ 3%.
Yield curve / term structure. One discount rate for all flows is an oversimplification; on-the-run Treasuries imply a term structure. Normal shape: upward — term premium (a type of risk premium) for rising rates (price falls), unexpected inflation, default risk (more relevant outside US). Drivers: - Monetary policy — central banks set overnight rates; expected policy moves long yields; QE buys longer bonds. - Rate expectations — long yields reflect expected future short rates. - Market forces — investors choose a long bond vs rolling shorter bonds, buying the more attractive. (This is the forward-rate/expectations logic; slides don't name "expectations theory" or forward-rate formulas.)
Inverted: market expects lower future rates (slowdown/recession → Fed cuts), common after aggressive tightening; term premium overwhelmed by expectations. Eurozone: France trades at a spread to Germany (perceived risk, liquidity); Euro yields below US despite US being "safer" — FX must be considered.
B — Credit Spreads, Duration & Convexity; Real Rates, Inflation & TIPS (L3A, L3B)
Lecture 3A — Credit, Yield Curve (cont.), Credit Spreads, Duration & Convexity
Credit vocabulary (L3A reading slide) - Credit = provision of funds in exchange for a promise of future repayment (credit card ≠ debit card). - Credit markets = markets for debt instruments (bonds and loans). In practice "credit" means credit-sensitive debt, esp. corporate bonds and loans. Treasuries are "rates," not "credit." - So "I trade credit" = I trade the credit-risk component of debt — e.g. buy/sell corporates on a view that their spread over Treasuries will narrow/widen (HW3 Q2.10).
Bond pricing conventions (L3A, HW2 tips) - Quoted per 100 of face. On $1M face: 100 → $1M (par), 99.5 → $995,000 (discount), 100.5 → $1,005,000 (premium). - Zeros: one "bullet" payment of face at maturity, trade at a discount. A coupon bond = a portfolio of zeros — which is why you can price it off the spot curve. - Long = own it, want price ↑. Short = borrow and sell, owe it, want price ↓. Position = amount owned (long) or owed from a short sale (short).
Yield curve pieces that live in L3A - Model bond markets by looking at rates first, then derive prices. Yields mean-revert: 10-yr long-run average ≈ 6%; last-20-yr average ≈ 3%. - Normal (upward) curve = term premium (a type of risk premium; "term" = time to maturity) for rising-rate risk, unexpected inflation, default risk (more relevant outside the US). - Shape drivers: monetary policy (Fed sets overnight rate; QE buys longer bonds), expected future short rates, and market arbitrage between one long bond vs rolling shorts. - Inverted curve: market expects lower future rates (slowdown → Fed cuts); common after aggressive tightening. Term premium is overwhelmed by rate expectations. Standard steepness measure: 2s10s spread; inversion historically precedes recession. HW3 Q1.3 official reasoning: ignoring term premium, a long rate ≈ average of expected short rates, so long < short ⇒ market expects short rates to fall. - Trades: steepener = long 2-yr, short 10-yr (profits if 10-yr yield rises relative to 2-yr); flattener = reverse. Two-legged; three-legged = butterfly. - Spot (zero-coupon) curve: each point = yield on a single cash flow at that date. Spot → par curve: PV each cash flow at its spot, sum, convert to YTM. Par → spot: bootstrap from the short end. - Central bank (Fed: monetary policy, independent) vs finance ministry (Treasury: fiscal policy, issues bonds, political). Kept separate because politicians have short-term incentives to "print money" ⇒ future inflation. Türkiye inflation peaked at 85% in 2022.
Credit spreads (L3A) - Credit spread = corporate yield − Treasury yield of same maturity. Lower rating ⇒ wider spread (risk premium for default). - Term structure of credit spreads: spread curves are usually upward sloping (more time ⇒ more chances for adverse events; uncertainty about repayment grows with horizon). But spread curves can invert (market expectations, liquidity). - Other watched spread curves: MBS, munis, ABS, emerging markets. - Flight to safety (HW6 Q1.4): recession fears ⇒ investors rotate out of corporates into Treasuries ⇒ Treasury prices ↑ / corporate prices ↓ ⇒ spreads widen.
Duration (L3A slides 28–31) - On the price–yield curve, duration quantifies the (negative) slope. Negative slope ⇒ positive duration. Can duration be negative? No — price and yield always move opposite. - Macaulay duration \(D_M = \sum t\,w_t\), \(w_t = \frac{C_t/(1+r)^t}{P}\): PV-weighted average time to cash flows, in years. \(r\) = discount rate per period, usually YTM/2; compute in periods then divide by 2 for years. - High coupon ⇒ shorter duration; low coupon ⇒ longer. Zero-coupon bond: \(D_M = T\) (all weight on maturity). - Modified duration \(D_{mod} = \frac{D_M}{1+r} = -\frac{1}{P}\frac{dP}{dr}\): % price change per 1% (100 bp) yield change; linear approximation, ignores convexity. Dmod and DM are close, so pros just say "duration." - Proof (HW3 Q1.4): \(P = \sum C_t(1+r)^{-t}\) ⇒ \(\frac{dP}{dr} = -\sum t\,C_t(1+r)^{-t-1}\) ⇒ \(-\frac{1}{P}\frac{dP}{dr} = \frac{1}{1+r}\cdot\frac{1}{P}\sum t\frac{C_t}{(1+r)^t} = \frac{D_M}{1+r}\). Interpretation: duration is the bond's interest-rate risk — a bond with \(D_{mod}=7\) loses ≈7% for +1% in yields. - Longer maturity (same coupon) ⇒ larger duration ⇒ more price-sensitive: more value sits in distant cash flows, which discounting hits hardest (HW3 Q1.5).
Convexity (L3A slides 29, 32; L3B slides 5–6) - Curvature of price–yield curve; 2nd derivative: \(C = \frac{1}{P}\frac{d^2P}{dr^2}\) (= change in duration per unit change in yield). - \(\frac{\Delta P}{P} \approx -D_{mod}\,\Delta y + \tfrac{1}{2} C\,(\Delta y)^2\) — "essentially a two-term Taylor series about the current YTM." - Positive convexity always helps the bondholder, whether yields rise or fall (price rises more than duration predicts, falls less). Given equal yield/duration/liquidity/credit, hold the more convex bond (HW3 Q2.4). - Can convexity be negative? Yes — not for standard bonds, but for MBS/ABS and bonds with embedded options (callables). - L3A slide 28 graph (2/10/30-yr, same coupon): 30-yr is most curved because more value comes from distant cash flows. Curves intersect at 100 (par) where yield = coupon (HW3 Q2.8). YTM = coupon ⇒ par is provable from the annuity formula (HW3 Q2.5).
Spot-curve pricing (HW3 Q1.1–1.2) - Price a coupon bond by discounting each semiannual cash flow at its own spot (semiannual compounding): 5-yr 4% bond → 96.77, YTM 4.73%, \(D_M\) 4.57 yrs. Zero yield interpolated at 4.57 yrs = 4.63% — the coupon bond's YTM is higher than the duration-matched zero on an upward curve because YTM is pulled toward the final (largest, longest) cash flow's spot. - Note: the HW3 "Partial Solutions" page labels are shifted one row (the "Q1.2" line is the Q1.1 answer; "Q1.3" line is Q1.2).
CFO's view (HW3 Q1.6): want your outstanding bonds' price ↑ (yield ↓) — either your spread tightened (market sees lower default risk) or Treasury yields fell; both lower the coupon needed on future issuance.
Lecture 3B — Inflation, Real vs Nominal Rates, TIPS
Reading (TIPS) - TIPS principal is tied to CPI; TIPS yields are real yields: nominal yield = real yield + inflation. - Breakeven inflation = same-maturity Treasury yield − TIPS yield = market's CPI forecast (the inflation rate at which you're indifferent between the two). - Real yields can be negative: demand for inflation protection was so high that investors accepted a negative real yield, believing alternatives (incl. very-low-yield nominal Treasuries) would fare worse.
Inflation measurement (L3B) - "Notoriously difficult to measure." BLS computes CPI, Core CPI (ex food & energy), PPI. - Is inflation ever good? Yes — for a net borrower (reduces what you owe in real terms). For anyone with net positive financial assets, inflation is bad. Real assets (real estate, precious metals, commodities) hold value. - Deflation also hurts: CPI fell 27% in the Great Depression. Mechanisms (HW3 Q3.4): people delay spending/investment expecting lower prices; real burden of fixed nominal debt rises ⇒ distress. Fed goal = price stability ≈ 2% inflation.
Fisher equation (L3B slides 11–12) - Exact: \(1 + r = (1 + r^*)(1 + \pi)\); forward-looking uses expected inflation \(E[\pi]\). - Approx (small rates): \(r \approx r^* + \pi\) (drops the \(r^*\pi\) cross term). HW3 Q3.2: 5% nominal, 3% TIPS ⇒ exact 1.94%, approx 2.00%, gap ≈ 6 bp = \(r^*\pi\). - Implications: real rate = true cost of borrowing/lending after inflation; expected inflation ↑ ⇒ nominal rates ↑. - TIPS introduced 1997 — lets the market set lockable real rates; nominal − real = breakeven.
TIPS mechanics (L3B slide 13) - Principal indexed to CPI; fixed real coupon rate applied to the adjusted principal. - At maturity: greater of original or inflation-adjusted principal (deflation floor on principal only; coupons can shrink). - Nominal IRR of a held-to-maturity TIPS with constant inflation: \((1+\text{real yld per period})(1+\pi\text{ per period}) - 1\). HW3 Q3.1 → \(1.015 \times 1.02 - 1 = 3.53\%\) per half = 7.06% annual (bond-equivalent; 7.18% EAR). No official number is printed (spreadsheet link only).
Trades & purchasing power - Expect inflation below breakeven ⇒ short TIPS, long nominals (duration-matched). Above breakeven ⇒ long TIPS, short nominals (HW3 Q3.6). - Preserving purchasing power: TIPS, real estate, commodities, equities with pricing power — their cash flows/values adjust with prices, unlike fixed nominal coupons (HW3 Q3.5).
C — Stocks & Markets, Valuation, Calculating ROI (L4A, L4B, L5A)
L4A — Stocks & Stock Markets
Reading framing (Malkiel). Firm-foundation: an asset is worth its intrinsic value (PV of future cash flows). Flaw: depends on unknowable forecasts of growth and the discount rate. Castle-in-the-air: an asset is worth what the next buyer will pay — res tantum valet quantum vendi potest ("a thing is worth only what someone will pay for it"). Flaw: no anchor; explains bubbles (tulips) but can't price anything. Value vs growth is a different axis from firm-foundation vs castle-in-the-air.
Buffett (L4A). Disney, AmEx, GEICO, Coca-Cola, Apple, See's Candies. 1976–2006 beat the S&P 500 in 27 of 31 years by an average 11.1%/yr; t-statistic > 3 ⇒ skill in addition to luck. Strategies: thorough research, big bets, patience (long horizon), activism.
Capital structure = right-hand side of the balance sheet (debt + equity). VC-backed startup ⇒ almost all equity (preferred). Private equity ⇒ debt-heavy (LBOs, see L4B).
Common vs preferred (L4A). | | Common | Preferred | |---|---|---| | Votes | Yes | Typically no (exceptions, esp. VC-funded cos.) | | Dividends | Variable, based on performance | Fixed (or none — typical for VC preferred) | | Liquidation | Last | Priority over common (still junior to debt) |
Why issue stock? Raise capital for expansion, operations, or debt repayment. You are buying ownership (equity) = a claim on future profits. Private cos. raise in rounds (Seed, Series A, B, C…). First public sale = IPO (primary market: company sells new shares to investors). Later public issuance = FPO (follow-on public offering) — more common than IPOs, less publicized. Afterwards shares trade on the secondary market (NYSE, Nasdaq); the company receives nothing from secondary trades (L6B) but still wants its price up.
Public vs private. Public: exchange-listed, liquid, regulated, mandatory disclosure. Private: restricted ownership, private negotiation, illiquid. VC and PE both hold private stock (separate categories).
Indices (L4A). DJIA: "arguably the worst index, nevertheless the most quoted" — 30 hand-picked blue chips, price-weighted (a $1,000 stock moves it 10× a $100 stock for the same % move, regardless of market cap). S&P 500: cap-weighted, rules-based, ~80% of US cap, "most used by market professionals." Nasdaq Composite: ~3,000, cap-weighted, tech-skewed. Russell 2000: small-cap benchmark.
Size and style. Stocks bucketed by market cap (thresholds vary by institution; Morningstar uses its own method). Value vs growth: no agreed line; key metrics are P/E (or earnings yield E/P), dividend yield, earnings growth rate. Value: low P/E, higher dividends, lower volatility (financials, staples, energy; KO, JPM, XOM). Growth: high P/E, reinvest earnings, more volatile (tech, healthcare, discretionary; AMZN, NVDA, TSLA).
Stocks vs bonds. Stock = ownership; dividends + capital gains; no maturity; votes (common); paid last. Bond = loan; fixed coupons + principal; maturity date; no votes but covenants; paid first. Covenants = contractual restrictions set by lenders/bond issuers as conditions for funding: debt-to-equity limits, interest-coverage minimums, dividend restrictions, change-of-control restrictions. Purpose: protect creditors from actions that raise default risk.
Hybrids (JP's two): (1) corporate bonds — debt, but credit risk tied to company performance, so they trade partly like equity; (2) preferred stock — equity, but fixed dividends and liquidation priority like debt. (Convertibles are the textbook hybrid; the lecture names these two.)
Strategies, part 1. Fundamental: intrinsic value via DCF, buy when price < value, long horizon (Graham, Munger/Buffett, sell-side analysts, many funds). Technical: price patterns, volume, psychology — momentum, mean reversion, breakout/support-resistance; day traders, swing traders (days–weeks), some quant/HFT. Candlesticks (Japan, 1700s) show four prices: body = open–close, wicks = high/low; green rising, red falling. Sentiment/behavioral: sentiment = short-term mood; behavioral = long-term mispricing/mean reversion; contrarian, herd/FOMO, bias exploitation (loss aversion, recency). Soros (reflexivity: perceptions ↔ fundamentals ⇒ instability); Kahneman & Tversky founded behavioral finance (psychologists, not investors). Quant/algorithmic: stat arb, HFT (tiny profit × many trades), AI models. Jim Simons/RenTech Medallion: 66% gross, 39% net avg annual, 1988–2018.
L4B — Investing & Trading (cont.), Valuing Common Stocks
Short activism (Nikola/Hindenburg). Publicly exposing negative facts is legal if accurate, illegal if false. Timing is hard ("last fool"). Nikola raised $800M, peaked at $34B, Ch. 11 in Feb 2025.
Strategies, part 2. Macro & event-driven: rates, inflation, FX, geopolitics, M&A/earnings events, commodities. Dalio, Paulson (\(4B shorting MBS, 2008), Soros (Bank of England, 1992). *Activist*: big stakes to force changes (leadership, buybacks, cost cuts), short activism, hostile takeovers/LBOs. Icahn (Apple, Xerox), Ackman (Chipotle, Herbalife); 2013: Ackman ~\)1B short Herbalife, Icahn long ⇒ short squeeze. Market making: bid-ask spread (HFTs retail, IBs institutional). Derivatives: option spreads, vol, structured products. Summary = 8 strategies.
Traders vs investors (HW4). Traders: short horizon, trading gains, higher short-term risk. Investors: long horizon, fundamentals, income + appreciation.
Yahoo! Finance quote. TTM = trailing twelve months (backward-looking EPS). Earnings dots come from 10-Q (quarterly, unaudited) and 10-K (annual, audited). Ex-dividend date = first day the stock trades without the right to the upcoming dividend (L5A's corrected wording). Price drops by ≈ the dividend at the open: \(P_{before} = P_{after} + D\) (HW4: \(80 − 1.25 = 78.75\)). Other filings: 8-K = current report on major events (M&A, exec changes, bankruptcy, major agreements, bond issues); 13D = holder acquires >5% of voting shares and may seek influence (13D/A = amendment; passive holders file 13G).
Valuation methods. - Cash-flow: DCF (project cash flows, discount at required return) and DDM (PV of dividends; for stable payers). \(P_0 = \sum_{t\ge1} \frac{DIV_t}{(1+r)^t}\), or with horizon \(H\): \(P_0 = \sum_{t=1}^{H}\frac{DIV_t}{(1+r)^t} + \frac{P_H}{(1+r)^H}\). They agree in theory: retained cash isn't lost — it eventually returns to owners as dividends or a liquidity event; otherwise the stock would be worthless. - Comps: Comparable company analysis (current multiples of similar public firms: P/E, P/S, P/B) and precedent transactions (multiples paid in recent M&A).
L5A — Valuation Review, Calculating ROI
All four are highly uncertain (projection accuracy and length, terminal assumption — typically Gordon steady growth; comp similarity and adjustments; markets changed since precedents). Why use them? Public cos.: spot significant mispricing ⇒ trades. Private cos.: they're all you have ⇒ use all four, take a weighted average ("very important for entrepreneurs").
Return from holding stock. From Gordon \(P_0 = \frac{DIV_1}{r-g}\): \(r = \frac{DIV_1}{P_0} + g\) (dividend yield + growth). \(DIV_1\) must match the period of \(r\), \(g\) (annual with annual).
ROI components. Income (dividends) + capital gains/losses (realized when sold, unrealized while held). Tax: gains taxed lower than income; losses offset gains (sometimes income); triggered only on realization. Course usually ignores taxes.
Total Return. \(TR = \frac{P_1 - P_0 + D}{P_0}\). "Flawed": ignores TVM on dividends (mid-period dividends ⇒ true ROI higher). Used because SEC requires it for mutual funds/ETFs/REITs, simplicity, precedent. Fix: reinvest dividends at some \(r\), or better, choose periods matching the dividend cycle so dividends fall at period ends; annualize a TR over \(T\) years with \((1+TR)^{1/T} - 1\).
CAGR. Geometric, not arithmetic mean: 10% then 20% ⇒ \(\sqrt{1.1\cdot1.2}-1 = 14.89\%\), not 15%. Over \(N\) periods of \(T\) years: \(CAGR = \left[\prod (1+R_i)\right]^{1/(NT)} - 1\). Price-only: \((P_{end}/P_{begin})^{1/T}-1\) (also used for revenue, profits, index levels). With dividends reinvested (SEC-required for funds): chain \(\frac{P_i + D_i}{P_{i-1}}\) over dividend-aligned periods.
Risk (intro). Risk = volatility (uncertainty) or probability of loss — not the same, but directly related for a fixed horizon. Market (systematic) vs idiosyncratic; only idiosyncratic diversifies away; market risk can be hedged (e.g., short the market).
HW-linked extras (HW5 Q3, HW6 Q4, Q7)
Malkiel's market-return estimate: \(E[R] \approx\) dividend yield + earnings growth + annual % change in P/E, where P/E change \(= (PE_{end}/PE_{now})^{1/n} - 1\). HW5: 1.5% + 8% − 4.74% ≈ 4.76% < 5.20% 10y Treasury.
Excess cash (Microsoft 2004, ~$56B). Low-yield cash hurts shareholders. Keep only if projects earn more than the opportunity cost of capital; otherwise return it. Buyback ⇒ fewer shares (anti-dilution) ⇒ EPS and price per share up vs a dividend. Executives like buybacks (pay tied to price/EPS, options); shareholders like them for taxes (lower capital-gains rate, deferred until sale). Buybacks were illegal 1934–1982; 1% excise tax now (L5B).
Capital markets (HW6 Q7). Sell side (Goldman, MS, JPM) sells new issues to the buy side (pensions, mutual/hedge funds, PE, insurers, SWFs). Penny stocks fail listing rules ⇒ OTC. Clearinghouse guarantees settlement. Block bid below screen: seller buys immediacy, dealer bears inventory risk, no guaranteed profit.
D — Risk & Diversification, CAPM, Market Efficiency & Corporate Finance (L5B, L6A, L6B)
L5B — Risk vs Return, Diversification
CAGR (L5B). Use the geometric mean: +10% then +20% averages \(\sqrt{1.1 \times 1.2} - 1 = 14.89\%\), not 15%. TR ignores dividend timing, so match periods to the dividend cycle. With dividends reinvested, TR = IRR.
What is risk? (L5B). In finance, risk means either (1) uncertainty of outcomes, i.e. volatility (standard deviation of returns), or (2) probability of loss. Volatility is the main measure because it captures the spread of returns around the mean (HW6 Q1.1). VaR covers the probability-of-loss meaning: a one-day 99% VaR of $X means a 1% chance of losing $X or more in a day. With normal returns and a mean near zero, \(\text{VaR}_{99} = 2.33\,\sigma_{daily} \times \text{Value}\) (HW6 Q1.2: \(2.33 \times 1.5\% \times \$12M = \$419{,}400\)).
Two kinds of risk (L5B). - Market (systematic) risk: broad factors that hit every security. Examples: economic cycles, interest-rate changes, inflation or deflation, geopolitical events, natural disasters, pandemics. - Idiosyncratic risk: specific to one investment or one sector. Examples: credit (default) risk, liquidity risk, product failure or obsolescence, political or regulatory risk, management changes. - Diversification can reduce or eliminate idiosyncratic risk but not market risk. Market risk can be hedged, for example by shorting the whole market.
Risk premium (L5B). Take two assets with the same expected cash flows. The riskier one trades at a lower price and so has a higher expected return. Example: a junk bond and a Treasury with identical payouts. The junk bond sells for less because of default and liquidity risk, so its yield is higher. Whole asset classes carry premiums too (stocks vs T-bills since 1899). US stocks: mean ≈ 10%, σ ≈ 20%.
A/B/C example (L5B): A (10%, σ 15%), B (10%, σ 7.5%), C (20%, σ 7.5%). C dominates both. A risk-seeker might still want A for its chance at a large payout.
Ranking distributions (HW5 Q4.2, official answer): Expected return cannot be ranked from volatility alone. If the assets are individual securities, part of their σ is idiosyncratic and earns no reward. Only if they are well-diversified portfolios, where all remaining risk is systematic, does CAPM let you say that more σ means more expected return.
Diversification (L5B; L6B slide 8). Portfolio σ falls as stocks are added and approaches the market (systematic) risk floor asymptotically (NYSE random-portfolio chart, 2010–2019). The part above the floor is idiosyncratic. For an equal-weight portfolio of \(N\) stocks with the same σ and pairwise ρ: \(\sigma_p^2 = \sigma^2/N + (1 - 1/N)\rho\sigma^2 \to \rho\sigma^2\). Higher correlation means a higher floor and a flatter curve, so diversification helps less. For diversifying, pick assets with low correlation. An anti-correlated asset is ideal because it can in theory cancel the other asset's risk; that is a hedge. International holdings help, but cross-country correlations are mostly positive (globalization).
Risk-free rate (HW5 Q4.4). Use a zero-coupon Treasury whose maturity matches the investment horizon (STRIPS go out to 30 years). Coupon Treasuries are not strictly risk-free over the horizon because the coupons carry reinvestment risk.
L6A — Markowitz Bullet, Portfolio Theory, CAPM
Two-asset portfolio (L5B/L6A, HW5 Q5). \(E[R_p] = w_A E[R_A] + w_B E[R_B]\), and \(\sigma_p = \sqrt{(w_A\sigma_A)^2 + (w_B\sigma_B)^2 + 2w_Aw_B\rho\sigma_A\sigma_B}\). Sweeping the weights traces the Markowitz bullet (Southwest/Amazon in lecture). A very risk-averse investor picks the minimum-variance point; a very risk-tolerant one picks 100% of the higher-return asset. - \(\rho = +1\): \(\sigma_p = w_A\sigma_A + w_B\sigma_B\). The bullet becomes a straight line, with no diversification benefit. - \(\rho = -1\): \(\sigma_p = |w_A\sigma_A - w_B\sigma_B|\). The bullet becomes two line segments meeting at σ = 0 where \(w_A\sigma_A = w_B\sigma_B\), i.e. \(w_A = \sigma_B/(\sigma_A+\sigma_B)\). This is a synthetic risk-free asset. Can its return exceed \(r_f\)? "Yes in theory, but no in an arbitrage-free world": otherwise you could borrow at \(r_f\) and lock in a riskless profit.
Efficient frontier (L6A). With many assets, the frontier is the upper edge of the feasible set: maximum E for each σ, or equivalently minimum σ for each E. Only one individual stock lies on it, the highest-expected-return stock, because the frontier's top end has to be 100% in that stock. Markowitz is the father of Modern Portfolio Theory (MPT).
Adding the risk-free asset (L6A). Mixing any portfolio with the risk-free asset gives a straight line through \(r_f\), because the risk-free asset has zero σ and zero covariance. The best such line is tangent to the bullet at the tangency portfolio T. To the left of T you are lending; to the right you are borrowing, i.e. shorting the zero-coupon Treasury (leverage). In theory there is no cap on expected return because leverage is unlimited.
Sharpe ratio (L6A): \(S = (E[R_p] - r_f)/\sigma_p\), the slope of that line. It is the extra expected return per 1% of added volatility, and higher is better. All rational investors hold T plus a long or short position in the zero. Risk preference only sets how much they lend or borrow, and the optimum is where an investor's indifference curve touches the line (two-fund separation).
Market portfolio and CML (L6A). In equilibrium T equals the market portfolio. Mechanism (NVDA example): if everyone wants more NVDA than the market holds, they bid its price up. Its market weight rises and its expected return falls until people are content to hold the market portfolio again. Holding the market diversifies away all idiosyncratic risk. The line through T is the capital market line: \(E[R_p] = r_f + \frac{E[R_m]-r_f}{\sigma_m}\sigma_p\).
Why only systematic risk is priced (L6A). Take assets A and B with the same E and the same total σ, where A's risk is mostly idiosyncratic and B's mostly systematic. Investors buy A and diversify its risk away. That pushes A's price up and its expected return down until bearing idiosyncratic risk earns nothing. Before MPT, people believed return tracked total risk.
Beta (L6A). $\(\beta_i = \frac{\text{Cov}(R_i,R_m)}{\sigma_m^2} = \rho_{i,m}\frac{\sigma_i}{\sigma_m}\)$ Beta is a scaled correlation coefficient. Equivalently, it is the ratio of risk premiums: \(\beta = (r_i - r_f)/(r_m - r_f)\) (HW6 Q3.2). The market has β = 1. An asset uncorrelated with the market has β = 0 and so earns \(r_f\), however volatile it is (HW6 Q3.5). Betas are estimated empirically by regression.
CAPM / SML (L6A): \(E[R_i] = r_f + \beta_i(E[R_m] - r_f)\), where \(E[R_m] - r_f\) is the market risk premium. Each asset's risk premium is proportional to its β. The SML's x-axis is β, not σ. JP's slide misspells it "CAMP pricing equation" (BMA §8-2 has the derivation).
Alpha (L6A): the average gap between realized returns and the CAPM prediction, estimated by the regression \(r_{i,t} - r_f = \alpha_i + \beta_i(r_{m,t} - r_f) + \varepsilon_t\).
L6B — CAPM Limits, Market Efficiency, Corporate Finance
CAPM assumptions (L6B, "highly idealized"): (1) investors are rational and, on average, risk-averse; (2) only systematic risk matters because investors diversify away idiosyncratic risk; (3) markets are frictionless (no transaction costs, borrowing constraints, or taxes) and efficient. Every investor holds the same risky portfolio and differs only in lending or borrowing. CAPM is a single-factor model. The Fama-French three-factor model uses beta, market cap, and "value" (price-to-book). The US Steel vs Newmont slide asks whether a higher CAPM expected return makes the high-β stock better. No: the extra return only pays for extra market risk.
EMH (Fama, L6B). An efficient market's prices fully reflect available information, so there are no consistent excess returns.
| Form | Prices reflect | Can't beat it with | Evidence |
|---|---|---|---|
| Weak | past prices and volume | technical analysis | generally supported (momentum and mean reversion observed) |
| Semi-strong | all public info | fundamental analysis | partially supported (fast reactions; but over- and under-reaction, post-earnings drift, irrational exuberance) |
| Strong | all info incl. private | anything | not supported (insider trading; funds with privileged access generate alpha) |
Paradox: markets have to be slightly inefficient to give traders a reason to trade, and that trading is what makes them efficient.
Corporations (L6B). A corporation is a separate legal entity formed under state law, often Delaware, with ownership split into shares. It can own assets, sign contracts, borrow, and sue or be sued. Key features are limited liability, perpetual existence, and access to capital. They exist for risk management, economic growth, and liquidity. HW6 Q6 adds: sole proprietorships and partnerships give no liability protection. S-corps avoid double taxation but are capped at 100 owners, which makes them unattractive to VCs. C-corps allow unlimited shareholders. (The entity-comparison table on slide 19 is an image; these facts come from the HW6 solutions.)
Capital markets (L6B). Investment banks (GS, MS, JPM) underwrite new issues; this is the primary market. Commercial banks take deposits and make loans. On the secondary market, trading is either exchange-traded (with a clearinghouse guaranteeing settlement) or OTC (dealers, counterparty risk). The firm gets no proceeds from secondary trades. Dark pools handle about 40% of US volume.
E — Governance, Accounting, Financial Statements, Cash Flows & Double Entry (L7A, L7B, L8A)
L7A — Corporate Finance, Governance, Accounting Basics
Reading recap (L7A). Factor investing tries to raise returns and/or cut volatility relative to the CAPM benchmark; return above the CAPM prediction is alpha. Common factors beyond beta: momentum, value, small size, low volatility, "quality." In a perfect CAPM world factors are useless (everyone holds the market portfolio; beta is the only factor). PMs should target risk-adjusted return.
Corporation (L7A). Separate legal entity formed under state law (often Delaware), ownership split into shares; can own assets, contract, borrow, sue/be sued. Key features: limited liability, perpetual existence, access to capital (stocks and bonds).
Financing and markets (L7A). Investment banks (not commercial banks) underwrite new securities sold to institutions (pension, mutual, hedge, PE funds, insurers, sovereign wealth funds) = primary market. Secondary trading is either exchange-traded (centralized, regulated; NYSE, CBOT, NYMEX; a clearinghouse guarantees settlement) or OTC (dealer-to-party; FX, penny stocks, corporate/muni bonds, structured derivatives; counterparty risk). Market makers = the subset of dealers that regularly post bids and offers. JP's answer: a company buying back its own stock is a primary-market transaction. The "Chinese Wall" separates sales/trading/research from the IB side (M&A, capital markets, leveraged finance, private placements).
Governance (L7A, L7B). Shareholders elect the board and approve major decisions → Board oversees strategy/performance, appoints and supervises the CEO → CEO executes strategy, reports to board → C-suite reports to CEO, runs day-to-day. "Hourglass" shape: everything goes through the CEO, who is paid ~2–5x other execs. Boards meet ~quarterly; the Chairman facilitates, sets agendas, oversees votes, but the board acts as a body. Good governance ensures transparency, accountability, ethics, compliance, priority of shareholder interests. - Activist investors (L7B reading): e.g. John Rogers / Ariel (value, long-horizon, active, small/mid-cap) wrote to Mattel's board: company undervalued; sell to a strategic buyer or break up/divest units; hire an independent advisor.
Branches of accounting (L7A). - Financial: statements for external stakeholders. Public cos must follow SEC rules + GAAP; private cos often strive for GAAP to attract investors. - Tax: compliance/planning under IRS/local rules, generally different from GAAP (external). - Managerial & cost: internal decision-making and cost analysis. CPA: 6–18 months coursework, 1–2 yrs experience, 16-hour exam; ~40% of large-company CFOs are CPAs.
Three statements (L7A). BS = snapshot, \(A - L = E\), overall financial health. IS = period, Revenues − Expenses = Profits, performance. SoCF = derived from BS and IS, period, Operating / Investing / Financing, liquidity and sustainability.
L7B — Balance Sheet and Income Statement
Balance sheet (L7A–7B). Current means used/settled within one year. Assets listed in descending liquidity. Inventory → (sale) receivable → (payment) cash. - Prepaid expenses: already paid, goods/services not yet received (asset). - PP&E (fixed assets): long-term tangible; recorded at cost less accumulated depreciation. - Other assets: intangibles (patents, trademarks), tax credits. - Accrued = incurred but not yet paid/received (e.g. interest due, unpaid wages). - Equity = book value = residual. Capital stock = amount invested by shareholders at issuance; Retained earnings = cumulative profits − dividends. - Working capital (net current assets) = CA − CL.
Goodwill (L7B). Arises only when a company acquires another for more than the fair value of its net assets (\(A - L\)). Represents brand, loyalty, relationships. A company cannot book its own internally generated goodwill: no way to measure it without a transaction. Must be tested for impairment annually; impairment = write-down of the asset plus a reduction in earnings.
Ratios (L7B). - Current = CA/CL. Quick (acid test) = (CA − Inventory)/CL. Cash = Cash & equivalents / CL. - D/E = Total debt / Equity, where debt = interest-bearing liabilities only (not AP, accruals). - Liabilities-to-assets = TL/TA. Current ratio < 1 → current liabilities exceed liquid resources; may need to borrow, sell assets, or raise equity to pay near-term bills. High D/E → more leverage: fixed interest/principal claims, higher default risk, more volatile equity returns.
Income statement (L7B). - Top line = Revenue or Sales. Net sales = net of refunds and discounts. Revenue = income from all ordinary activities (sales plus fees, rent, royalties); for many firms the terms are synonymous. - COGS: costs directly tied to producing/acquiring what was sold; can include allocated fixed/semi-fixed costs (factory rent) and variable costs. - Gross profit ($) = Revenue − COGS; gross margin (%) = GP/Revenue. - Operating expenses: running the business, not directly tied to producing goods (S&M, R&D, G&A); casually "overhead," but overhead technically = all indirect costs and can sit in COGS (manufacturing overhead). - "COGS = variable, opex = fixed?" No. - EBIT = operating income = operating profit = operating earnings; usually the headline number. Operating loss → typically a tax loss carryforward. - Below the line: interest income/expense and taxes (except financial institutions), special one-time charges (impairment write-downs), non-operating items (sale of property). Net income = P&L = bottom line. - Margins: gross, operating (EBIT/Rev), profit (NI/Rev). - Sales are goods/services delivered, not cash received (under accrual). - Cash vs accrual: cash recognizes revenue/expense when cash moves (simple, small business, distorts multi-period deals). Accrual recognizes revenue when earned and matches expenses to revenue (matching principle); more accurate; required by GAAP for public companies. - Link: closing the books moves NI − dividends into RE. NI ≠ cash (depreciation is a non-cash expense).
L8A — Statement of Cash Flows and Double-Entry
Reading recap (L8A). \(P = E \times P/E\). Forward P/E fell from 22.2 to 19.3 ("three turns") while the S&P was up 19.9% YTD → valuations down, earnings up. Long-run earnings growth ≈ nominal GDP (~5–6%). Leverage ratio = debt/EBITDA. Paramount–WBD was a cash acquisition (alternative: stock acquisition); no price jump expected on closing day since markets react to new information.
SoCF (L8A). Start cash + cash received − cash spent = end cash. "Companies do not fail due to a lack of net income. They fail when they run out of cash." Cash is King. - Non-cash items (affect IS/BS, not SoCF): shipping product, receiving supplies or raw materials, depreciation, write-downs/impairments, equity-based compensation (Buffett 1992: options are compensation, compensation is an expense; rules changed 2005). - Sources: operating (customer payments), financing (stock, borrowing). Uses: operating (suppliers, employees), financing (interest, principal, dividends), CapEx, taxes. - Expenses → IS; payments → SoCF. Under cash accounting, IS ≈ SoCF. - CFO / CFI / CFF: CapEx raises PP&E, lowers cash (CFI). Net borrowings and stock sales are CFF. - Convention note: JP's sources/uses slide lists interest payments as a financing use; under US GAAP interest paid (and taxes paid) sit in CFO, dividends in CFF. Problems here use the GAAP layout. - Indirect method (not on slides; standard): CFO = NI + non-cash charges − ΔAR − ΔInventory − ΔPrepaid + ΔAP + ΔAccrued (asset up = cash down; liability up = cash up). Direct method: list cash collected minus cash paid by category. Same CFO either way.
Double-entry (L8A). \(A = L + E\); expanded: \(A = L + \text{Contributed capital} + \text{Initial RE} + \text{Revenue} - \text{Expenses} - \text{Dividends}\). Every journal entry has equal debits (left) and credits (right). - DR increases assets and expenses (and dividends); decreases liabilities, equity, revenue. CR does the reverse. - Contra accounts move opposite to their pair: accumulated depreciation (contra-asset to PP&E), sales discounts (contra-revenue). - Lecture examples: issue stock $500k (DR Cash / CR Common shares); rent $9k (DR Rent exp / CR Cash); computers $2,500 (DR Computers 2,500 / CR Cash 1,000 / CR AP 1,500); credit sale $10,000 at 8% tax, 2% discount → DR AR 10,800 / CR Sales 10,000 / CR Sales tax payable 800; on early payment DR Cash 10,584, DR Sales discount 200, DR Sales tax payable 16 / CR AR 10,800. - T-accounts visualize each account (debits left, credits right). Closing: Revenue − Expenses − Dividends → RE.
Part 3 — Discrepancies, Errors & Convention Traps
These came up while cross-checking the lectures, the homework solutions and the earlier version of these files. Know them, because CBTF answers follow one convention.
Errors or oddities in the official homework materials
- HW3 Partial Solutions labels are shifted by one. The line labeled "Q1.2" actually holds the Q1.1 answers (price 96.77, YTM 4.73%, duration 4.57). The line labeled "Q1.3" holds the Q1.2 answer (zero yield 4.63%). All the numbers themselves check out.
- HW5 Q1.3 (Red Bull P/E comps): mean P/E = (19.30 + 37.93)/2 = 28.615, and 28.615 × $1.78B = \(50.93B, or **\)509.35/share**. The official solution says $50.62B / \(506, which looks like an arithmetic slip. The P/S answer (\)437) checks out.
- HW5 Q4.3: the solution says higher correlation means "it takes more stocks to converge". In fact the diversification floor rises (σ_p → √(ρ̄)·σ̄), and the curve flattens and reaches its higher floor sooner. See D10.
- HW6 Q2.1 betas aren't printed in the solutions, and no market correlations are given. The only method consistent with the data is to back them out of CAPM: \(\beta = (E[R]-r_f)/\text{MRP}\), giving ABC = 0.9 and XYZ = 2.1. The max-Sharpe answer, 30% ABC / 70% XYZ, Sharpe 0.335, matches the official solution.
- HW6 Q3.4: the extracted formula reads "β = ρσ_A". It should be \(\beta = \rho\,\sigma_A/\sigma_M\). The answer (1.6) is right.
- HW6 Q6.1(ii): the official answer recommends a C-corp for the wingsuit school "for global scale", which looks copy-pasted from the Skydrop question. For a small, high-liability local business, an LLC is the standard answer.
- HW7 Q4.7 table: 195 − 62.2 = 132.8, which the table rounds to 133. Margins computed from the table's figures are fine.
- No numeric official answers exist for:
- HW3 Q3.1 (TIPS nominal IRR). Computed: 3.53% per half-year = 7.06% bond-equivalent, 7.18% EAR.
- HW4 Q5.3 (pair trade).
- HW5 Q2, Q3.1, Q3.3. Computed: Malkiel S&P estimate = 1.5% + 8% − 4.74% = 4.76%. 30y bond sold after 10y: 8.29% / 6.21% / 4.40% annual return at 2.75% / 4.75% / 6.75%.
Lecture vs textbook conventions (use the lecture's version on the exam)
- Bond default convention: the lectures and HW use semiannual coupons, with YTM compounding at the coupon frequency, for Treasuries, STRIPS and most corporates. The first version of the practice set said "annual unless stated". That's now fixed.
- Modified duration: the lecture writes \(D_{mod} = D_{Mac}/(1+r)\) with r per period, which is the same as \(D/(1+y/m)\).
- Spot/forward rates and the "expectations / liquidity preference" names come from BMA, not the slides. The slides frame the curve's shape through the term premium, rate expectations, monetary policy/QE, and the long-bond vs rolling-short-bonds argument. Know both.
- Credit spread composition: BMA says expected default loss + default risk premium + liquidity + taxes. The lecture says it's a risk premium for default that grows with maturity. The two don't conflict.
- Hybrid securities: JP's two examples are corporate bonds and preferred stock. Convertibles are the textbook's go-to.
- Primary-market follow-on: the lecture's term is FPO (follow-on public offering), which is more common than IPOs. BMA calls it an SEO. JP also counts a company buying back its own stock as a primary-market transaction.
- "ROI" lecture (L5A) is about total return, realized vs unrealized gains, income vs capital gains, CAGR and annualizing. The earlier cheatsheet's "payout × ROE sustainable growth" material is BMA 4-3, not L5A. Both are kept.
- Strong-form EMH: the lecture says it's not supported, because insiders earn abnormal returns. The old cheatsheet's phrasing ("kills insider profits") stated what strong form would imply.
- Market risk: it can't be diversified away, but JP stresses that it can be hedged (e.g., by shorting index futures).
- Risk-free rate for a horizon: use a zero-coupon Treasury matching the horizon. Coupon Treasuries carry reinvestment risk.
- D/E ratio: the lecture uses interest-bearing debt only, not total liabilities. Liabilities-to-assets uses total liabilities.
- Interest paid on the cash flow statement: JP's sources/uses slide lists interest payments with financing. US GAAP puts interest paid in CFO. The problem set uses GAAP and notes the difference.
- Goodwill impairment placement: the lecture puts it below the line. Under US GAAP it usually sits inside operating income.
- Direct vs indirect cash flow methods aren't named in the slides (they only show O/I/F). They're standard, and they're included in the problem set.
Formulas that were images in the decks
The extracted slide text didn't contain the formula images for duration and convexity (L3A), the Fisher equation (L3B), total return, CAGR and DDM horizon value (L5A), and the market-cap size table (L4A). The forms in these notes match the HW solutions where those exist, and the standard textbook forms otherwise. Skim those slides in the original decks to confirm the notation JP uses.